Court case win over nightmare garden

Melton Borough Council has successfully prosecuted a resident of New Street, Melton Mowbray following an ongoing case regarding an overgrown garden. 

Richard Bates was originally approached in September 2024 by the Council to address the overgrown vegetation in his front garden. When no engagement was received from Mr Bates, the case was escalated to the Safer Communities Team to investigate. This led to a series of formal written notices issued to the resident to carry out works at the property to clear the rubbish and vegetation at the property. 

When these notices were not complied with, a Fixed Penalty Notice was issued for the garden to be cleared, which was not paid or followed, leading to Melton Borough Council carrying out the works to cut back and properly dispose of all of the very overgrown vegetation and any other items that could provide food and harbour vermin. A rat’s nest was uncovered and treated as parts of the work. 

On 9 July 2025, the Council attended Leicestershire Magistrates’ Court to prosecute the case. Mr Bates did not attend the hearing, and the Court found the matter proved in his absence. He was fined £500 and was ordered to pay a contribution of £500 towards the Council’s costs of £1,157.10, and victim surcharge of £200, totalling £1,200.00. He will also be recharged for the cost of the works. 

Cllr Sarah Cox, Portfolio Holder for Corporate Finance, Property and Resources, said: “Even with support from our Tenancy Services Team and our Safer Communities Team, the resident failed to adhere to the conditions set out to him, forcing us to take necessary action to keep the area clean and free of pests.

"We take issues such as anti-social behaviour very seriously. If a supportive approach fails, we will not hesitate to enforce and act to keep our communities a safe and thriving place to live.” 

Anti-social behaviour can be reported online at www.melton.gov.uk/asb or alternatively by calling 01664 502502.  

~ends~ 

For more information please contact: communications@melton.gov.uk